A Place to Hide, A Place to Heal: A Battered Women’s Shelter for Orthodox Jews

A number of years ago, when I still worked as a balanit in the Mikvah (attendent at the ritual bath) in our yishuv, the Moetza Datit (religious authority) organized a few days of continuing education. One of the lecturers at this two day event was Dr. Shulamit Lehman, a social worker who works for Yad Sarah specializing in dealing with domestic violence. 

Her lecture was very informative and emotionally harrowing. I wrote notes, fully intending to write them up for a blog post, but I was so shaken by what I had heard that I couldn’t bring myself to do it. This past weekend I read an article in the Nashim supplement of Makor Rishon newspaper about a battered women’s shelter specifically for the religious community here in Israel, and I decided that I would dig up my notes and put together the post. 

Awareness of  the Problem 

There are many people who deny that domestic violence is a problem for the Jewish community as a whole, and for the religious community in particular. Dr. Lehman began her lecture by sharing that she too, had trouble accepting the fact that there was a problem – until she started working in the field. She stated that in the wider Israeli community one in 7 women were abused, and that studies showed that although the rates in the religious community were less, one in 10 religious women are abused. To prove her point further, she asked the women present to raise their hands if they knew of women abused in their community. The twenty women present at the lecture were mikveh attendants from religious yishuvim in the Shomron. I don’t want to sound elitist, but it is a fact that the people making up our yishuvim are generally middle or upper middle class and well educated. Therefore I was truly shocked when three women raised their hands. 

Dr. Lehman proceeded to describe some of the cases that she had dealt with through Yad Sarah, each sadder than the next. The most heartwrenching story for me was the one where she described how a little third grade girl would go to bed every night with a pair of scissors under her pillow…”just in case”. 

Special Factors Affecting the Religious Community 

There are special factors in the religious community that contribute to the problem of domestic abuse – or, more accurately, make it more difficult for a religious woman to escape. 

In our society women have very little or no experience dating, and therefore cannot always tell what is “normal”  in a relationship. There is quite a lot of pressure to get married, so even when a young woman suspects that something is wrong, her natural inclination is to gloss over the problem. Although physical contact before marriage is prohibited by halacha (Jewish law), sometimes this occurs anyway, especially between engaged couples. In this case a young woman will feel particularly pressured to go ahead with the marriage, even if she suffers abuse. 

Domestic abuse is characterized by controlling behavior by the husband, and many times the husband will blame the wife for their problems. This behavior erodes the woman’s self confidence, and it leads to a situation where she does not trust her own instincts. 

The stigma against divorce in our society is also a large contributing factor. If a religious woman somehow finds the courage to approach a girlfriend or her mother and expresses doubts about what is happening in her relationship – the natural reaction by the family is to shy away from the problem. Noone wants to acknowledge that someone in their immediate family has a problematic marriage which may lead to divorce. Therefore this channel of help is usually denied a woman who is looking to escape the abuse. 

Help is Available 

The lecture was given to us as mikva attendants because we are in a position to not only pick up on possible problems but also to be an objective source of help. Obviously there are many others that may be in a position to help. A friend or neighbor can sometimes become a confidant of someone suffering from abuse – so the following information is very important.

 The first thing to do if someone confides in you is to listen, and refrain from jumping in with solutions. Don’t be in a hurry to calm someone down or cover things up. At first you need to be a channel of communication for her. Your friend will then know that when she is ready to seek more help, that you are willing to listen to her and give credence to her feelings. 

Let your friend know that there are things that can be done, and that she is not alone in sufferring this problem. 

The Family Center at Yad Sarah (02-644-4514) provides treatment not only for victims of domestic abuse, but also for the men who are violent, and for the children who are “witnesses” and at greater risk to become perpetrators as adults. 

For those who must escape their situation immediately, there is a woman’s shelter specifically for religious women in Israel called Bat Melech (toll free number for their hotline in Israel is 1-800-292-333).The facility is set up with the special needs of the religious community in mind – Shabbat is observed, kashrut is kept (separate kitchen utensils are provided for women whose kashrut observances are stricter), and there is space for families with many children. The facility is manned by a group of dedicated workers, who help the women rebuild their lives and self-esteem, and keep up the relationship even after the women move out of the shelter.

 –written in the hope that no more children feel the need to go to sleep with scissors under their pillows…


12 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. aliyah06
    Aug 02, 2009 @ 11:41:43

    Bless you for publishing this!

    One of the most difficult parts of my former profession was domestic violence prosecutions. Your readers, and anyone you talk to, needs to know that domestic violence is NOT confined to a single socio-economic stratum; it is not dependent on age, or income, or education. It is hideously widespread throughout society. It is largely “learned behavior” (except where mental health and alcoholism are the LEADING factors–they may be present in learned behavior scenarios also) so it is important to protect the children, as the girls become future victims or abusive mothers, and the boys become abusers themselves.

    And women who are reading this and are in a domestic violence situation: it does NOT mean you are a failure! It means there is something wrong with HIM — and counseling to fix it, and/or leaving, are both excellent options until the violence stops. HIS violence is inexcusable –do not destroy your childrens’ futures by tolerating it. Get help now.

  2. Trackback: Domestic Violence in the Religious Zionist Community | A Mother in Israel
  3. ilanadavita
    Aug 02, 2009 @ 13:06:56

    Thanks for writing this post and providing links for the women who might need them.

  4. Batya
    Aug 02, 2009 @ 13:45:19

    Unfortunately, no one and no community is immune from it. I once had a ride from a woman who told me that she wasn’t surprised to hear that the man who had abused her daughter, causing her daughter to leave their home with their child and nothing else, had married again, and the second wife left, too.

    Frequently, when women are warned they don’t believe the stories are true.

  5. shaya g
    Aug 02, 2009 @ 19:33:29

    there is no excuse for abuse and everything should be done to protect the abused and potential victims. If possible, some help should try to be given to the abuser to try to prevent future incidents.

    I wonder though why we need to only discuss abused women whenever these issues come up. Men who are abused not only suffer the abuse, but worse emotional embarrassment from the fact that a male is being abused by a female. I know of a few cases where the female in the house is the dominant one, and she verbally and emotionally abuses her husband and kids daily. He can’t get help thru the Jewish system that is available, because it’s only available for women. Why do we force the men to seek help in the goyish support system, but the women get help, through a jewish network.

    NO ONE should be abused and this question is not meant to imply no one should be given help. But, while women certainly make up the majority of those being abused, we oughtn’t ignore anyone who is being abused, including the men!

  6. Milhouse
    Aug 03, 2009 @ 15:40:51

    Actually, Shaya G, women don’t make up the majority of those being abused. Every reputable study of domestic abuse and violence shows that it occurs approximately equally on both sides. Women are more likely than men to suffer serious injuries, because men tend to be stronger than women; but men are more likely than women to be killed by their partner, because women, since they tend to be weaker, are more likely to resort to weapons.

  7. Another West Bank Mama
    Aug 04, 2009 @ 05:38:49

    Thank you for publishing this. Do know, however, that some of the women who “know” families where abuse occurs, might be mistaken. One Shabbat, there were some loud noises, screams and bangs coming from our house (for a reason that was NOT domestic violence), and voila, two days after that, we had a social worker at our door telling me that the neighbours called to report my husband is probably hitting me. This misunderstanding hurt us so much that we’re thinking of moving out of the yishuv. No doubt everyone now thinks my husband is an abuser and I’m a victim.

  8. keren
    Aug 04, 2009 @ 07:09:12

    I posted this comment ona blog which linked to here, but here it is here too.
    This subject is discussed in (some) religious high schools for girls.
    A person called Noa Ariel (I think) has a fascinating puppet theatre.

    She presents a play about a girl getting meeting with a boy and finding out he was abusive (I myself did not see this, but my daughter did) It is aimed at the religious girls as descirbed in the post you linked to.
    This is followed up by a discussion with the girls.

    There are no magic tricks, but at least this brings the subject to their attention

  9. Judith usiskin
    Aug 04, 2009 @ 09:08:39

    the name of the woman who writes and produces ‘shows’ eg ‘Flowers are not enough’ is Naomi Ackerman -catch her on the www
    also look at jwa.org.uk and see what we are doing in the uk to try to fight dv in the community and preventt it in the future

  10. Tammy
    Aug 30, 2009 @ 04:08:01

    Firstly, thanks for this very important post! I have also had the opportunity to hear Dr. Lehman speak. She is excellent.

    Just wanted to clarify that Noa Ariel is indeed the name of the woman who does puppet theatre on the topic of abuse for high school girls in Israel.

  11. Bill Bartmann
    Sep 03, 2009 @ 22:05:01

    Excellent site, keep up the good work

  12. Trackback: Domestic Violence in the Religious Zionist Community

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: